Current:Home > BackFederal courts move to restrict ‘judge shopping,’ which got attention after abortion medication case-LoTradeCoin
Federal courts move to restrict ‘judge shopping,’ which got attention after abortion medication case
View Date:2024-12-23 21:05:29
WASHINGTON (AP) — Federal courts moved Tuesday to make it harder to file lawsuits in front of judges seen as friendly to a point of view, a practice known as judge shopping that gained national attention in a major abortion medication case.
The new policy covers civil suits that would affect an entire state or the whole country. It would require a judge to be randomly assigned, even in areas where locally filed cases have gone before a single judge.
Cases are already assigned at random under plans in most of the country’s 94 federal district courts, but some plans assign cases to judges in the smaller division where the case is filed. In divisions with only one judge, often in rural areas, that means private or state attorneys can essentially pick which judge will hear it.
The practice has raised concerns from senators and the Biden administration, and its use in patent cases was highlighted by Chief Justice John Roberts in his 2021 report on the federal judiciary.
Interest groups of all kinds have long attempted to file lawsuits before judges they see as friendly to their causes. But the practice got more attention after an unprecedented ruling halting approval of abortion medication. That case was filed in Amarillo, Texas, where it was all but certain to go before U.S. District Judge Matthew Kacsmaryk, an appointee of former President Donald Trump who is a former attorney for a religious liberty legal group with a long history pushing conservative causes.
The Supreme Court put the abortion medication ruling on hold, and is hearing arguments on it later this month.
The new policy announced by the U.S. Judicial Conference after its biennial meeting would not apply to cases seeking only local action. It was adopted not in response to any one case but rather a “plethora of national and statewide injunctions,” said Judge Jeff Sutton, chief judge of the 6th Circuit Court of Appeals and chair of the Judicial Conference’s executive committee.
“We get the idea of having local cases resolved locally, but when a case is a declaratory judgement action or national injunction, obviously the stakes of the case go beyond that small town,” he said.
veryGood! (4663)
Related
- Bitcoin has topped $87,000 for a new record high. What to know about crypto’s post-election rally
- Do food dyes make ADHD worse? Why some studies' findings spur food coloring bans
- At least 64 dead after Helene’s deadly march across the Southeast
- She defended ‘El Chapo.’ Now this lawyer is using her narco-fame to launch a music career
- Supreme Court seems likely to allow class action to proceed against tech company Nvidia
- 'Multiple' deaths reported after single-engine plane crashes in North Carolina
- College football Week 5 grades: Ole Miss RB doubles as thespian; cheerleader's ninja move
- Jalen Milroe, Ryan Williams uncork an Alabama football party, humble Georgia, Kirby Smart
- Volkswagen, Mazda, Honda, BMW, Porsche among 304k vehicles recalled: Check car recalls here
- Fierce North Carolina congressional race could hinge on other names on the ballot
Ranking
- UConn, Kansas State among five women's college basketball games to watch this weekend
- Anthony Richardson injury update: Colts QB removed with possible hip pointer injury
- Death of Stanford goalie Katie Meyer in 2022 leads to new law in California
- Yankees' Anthony Rizzo fractures fingers in season's penultimate game
- Ben Affleck and His Son Samuel, 12, Enjoy a Rare Night Out Together
- Ciara Reveals How Her Kids Have Stepped Up With Her and Russell Wilson's Daughter Amora
- Phillies become the hunted in MLB playoffs as NL East champs: 'We're ready for it'
- A handcuffed Long Island man steals a patrol car after drunk driving arrest, police say
Recommendation
-
Shel Talmy, produced hits by The Who, The Kinks and other 1960s British bands, dead at 87
-
MLB playoff scenarios: NL wild card race coming down to the wire
-
Opinion: Atlanta Falcons have found their identity in nerve-wracking finishes
-
Kristin Cavallari splits with 24-year-old boyfriend Mark Estes after 7 months
-
See Chris Evans' Wife Alba Baptista Show Her Sweet Support at Red One Premiere
-
3 easy mistakes can be deadly after a hurricane: What to know
-
Biden says he hopes to visit Helene-impacted areas this week if it doesn’t impact emergency response
-
Vance criticized an infrastructure law as a candidate then embraced it as a senator